Well report No. RR-7708 · T18N · R44W · SEC 18 · filed November 16, 2026

Petroleum MarketsWell report

$100 Oil Months Saw S&P 500 Fall 46.7% of the Time

S&P 500 fell 46.7% of the time in months after WTI closed above $100, versus 35.5% otherwise. A 489-month study calls it a lean, not a rule.

Field notes

  1. S&P 500 fell 46.7% of the time in months after WTI closed above $100, against 35.5% for other months.
  2. Study covers 489 months, January 1986 to September 2026; WTI closed at $100+ in 30 months across eight runs.
  3. Random-draw test (10,000 draws) found 1,521 matches with at least 14 falls, missing the pre-set statistical bar.
  4. WTI October reading stands at $103.37; 2026 runs saw the S&P 500 fall 5.09% in March and rise 10.42% in April.
Oil over $100: stocks fell more often after, 46.7% vs 35.5%
PlateOil over $100: stocks fell more often after, 46.7% vs 35.5% — AI-generated

By Olivia Hart

The S&P 500 fell 46.7% of the time in the month after WTI crude closed above $100, against 35.5% after all other months. That is the central finding of a study by SignalPilotLabs, published on TradingView, covering 489 months of data from January 1986 to September 2026. WTI's October reading in FRED, the St Louis Fed's database, stands at $103.37 — crude is back over the $100 mark.

What was measured?

The analysis paired monthly WTI closes (FRED series DCOILWTICO) with S&P 500 monthly closes (SP:SPX). WTI closed at $100 or more in 30 of the 489 months, grouped into eight distinct runs. The authors set their two tests and the statistical bar before pairing a single month — a pre-registered methodology designed to prevent cherry-picking.

The results split three ways:

  • The month after a $100-oil month: the S&P 500 fell 14 of 30 times, or 46.7%, versus 35.5% after other months.
  • The same month as the $100 close: the index fell 43.3% of the time, versus 35.5%.
  • The typical month after a $100-oil month returned +0.31%, against +1.31% for all other months.

The takeaway in plain words: months above $100 crude have coincided with weaker equity performance roughly half the time, but the return gap — one full percentage point — is the more telling figure.

Could the pattern be luck?

Both halves of the sample lean the same direction. From 1986 to 2010, the S&P 500 fell in 62.5% of months after $100 oil, against 36.3% for other months. Since 2010, the split is 40.9% against 34.1%.

But 30 months across eight runs is a thin record. When the authors drew 30 months at random 10,000 times, 1,521 draws — 15.2% — produced at least 14 falling months. That result misses the statistical bar the authors set in advance.

Their own verdict: a lean, not a rule.

Which years drove the record?

Eight runs account for all 30 months. Oil held above $100 for eight months in 2008, five months in 2014 and five months in 2022. The authors note that 2008, 2014 and 2022 were very different years, and the study does not isolate why crude was high in each case.

The 2026 episodes add nuance. WTI closed at $102.86 in March and $108.64 in April. The S&P 500 fell 5.09% in March — consistent with the historical lean — then rose 10.42% in April, which cuts firmly against it.

What does the chart show?

The published chart plots S&P 500 monthly closes from January 2007 to December 2015 on a logarithmic scale, where equal vertical steps represent equal percentage moves. Each run of $100-plus WTI months is shaded, with a mark over each month: orange when the S&P 500 fell, grey when it rose. Ten of the 23 shaded months are orange.

The authors first drew the full 2007-2026 span, but its 238 candles proved too thin to read. They narrowed the window to 2007-2015 after running the test — a change made for presentation only, not for the statistics.

What should traders and desks take from it?

The study's own framing is measured: $100 oil has accompanied weaker stock months more often than not, but on 30 observations the record cannot distinguish the pattern from chance. The authors' stated guidance is to treat it as a lean to watch, not a reason to sell.

The stated limitations are equally blunt. The analysis covers monthly closes and past data only. It does not address other crude price levels, other markets, or the underlying causes of each price spike.

The piece closes with a one-line disclaimer: observations, not recommendations.

The watch item

WTI at $103.37 for October puts the market back inside the historical test condition. The next monthly close — and the S&P 500's direction in the month that follows — adds one more observation to a 30-month record. Watch the November close.

via tradingview.com (Source)

Filed under

  • wti-crude-oil
  • s-p-500
  • 100-oil
  • market-correlation
Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Correspondent covering technology and product news in Oil and gas industry operations and markets at Rig & Refinery.

605 articles

Adjoining reports

« Previous articleNext article »